True American: The New Girl Drinking Game Rules (Sort Of)

True American is the drinking game from New Girl that nobody fully understands, and that is exactly why it works. The floor is lava, the table is the castle, and you shout the names of dead presidents while trying not to touch the ground. Here is a version with enough rules to actually play.

True American at a glance

WhatDetails
Players4 or more
You needLots of beer, one spirit bottle, furniture
Setup5 minutes and a cleared room
DifficultyGloriously chaotic
Chaos
5/5
Difficulty
4/5
Buzz level
5/5
Setup effort
3/5
Our take, 1 (low) to 5 (high).

What you will need to play

You do not need much to get going, but a few cheap staples make the night run smoother. Here is the kit we reach for.

What you need

  • A bunch of cans or bottles of beer, four per player is a good start
  • One bottle of spirit (“the secret”) for the center
  • A table in the middle of the room as the castle
  • Furniture to stand on, because the floor is lava

How to set up

  1. Put the table in the middle. Place the spirit bottle on top surrounded by a pyramid of beers, this is the castle.
  2. Everyone opens a beer. The floor is now lava. You cannot touch it.
  3. Players spread out standing on chairs, sofas and cushions around the room.

How to play

  1. Count off. Everyone puts in fingers on a count of “1, 2, 3, 4, JFK… FDR!” and the odd one out starts.
  2. Move on the zones. Players move across the furniture toward the castle without touching the floor. Touch the lava, take a drink and go back.
  3. Grab a beer from the castle when you reach it, but you must finish your current one first.
  4. Shout the chain. When someone yells a president quote, everyone must respond and drink. Miss it, drink again.
  5. Win the castle. The game ends when the spirit bottle (the secret) is claimed and finished by the group.

The golden rule

There is no official rulebook, and arguing about the rules is part of the game. Agree your house version before you start, keep the floor as lava throughout, and lean into the chaos.

Pro tips

  • Clear the breakables. People will be climbing on furniture. Move anything you would miss.
  • Cans over bottles. Less glass on a lava floor is a good idea.
  • Keep it light. Four beers plus a shared spirit adds up fast, so pace the group.
The floor is lava, the rules make no sense, and everybody drinks.

Pros and cons

Pros
  • Genuinely hilarious with the right group
  • The no-rules format means every game is different
  • A proper party centrepiece
Cons
  • Needs space and furniture you can stand on
  • The lack of firm rules can cause arguments

What you need to play

Related games

Frequently asked questions

What are the actual rules of True American?

There is no single official version. The constants are: the floor is lava, the center table holds a spirit bottle surrounded by beers, players cross furniture to reach it, and everyone drinks on the president chants. Agree the rest as a group.

How many people do you need?

At least four, but it is best with six or more. The more people climbing the furniture, the more chaotic and fun it gets.

Dan Smullen Beer is my life profile

Hi, I'm Dan, founder of BeerIsMyLife. I've been an avid homebrewer for over ten years, and beer is my true passion. I've traveled all over the world, visiting breweries, tasting beer, as well as making my own batches. I set up this blog to share that experience with you.