Baseball Drinking Game: A Complete Guide for Game Night Fun

Bounce, spin, and swish your way to game night fun with the ever-popular drinking game: Baseball! 

This classic twist on the traditional baseball game is an exciting way to bond with friends and family over prolonged innings of laughter and a good old-fashioned competitive spirit.

As teams take turns trying to bounce a ping-pong ball into four strategically placed cups, you’ll feel like you’re back in Little League or just having a good time at the pub.

How To Set Up The Baseball Drinking Game

The following are general guidelines on how to properly set up the baseball drinking game. 

Team Assembly

Assembling teams for the baseball-drinking game is essential in preparing for a fun and eventful game night. The recommended number of players per team is four. 

However, you can play with more or less, depending on your preference. It’s best to enforce equal numbers on each side so that nobody gets overwhelmed mid-game – plus, it’ll be even more fun! 

When assembling your teams, understand everyone’s ability levels so that the balance of power isn’t too unevenly slanted towards one team. Having a more extensive group also allows you to switch up teams every round, keeping all members engaged in the game.

Ping-Pong Ball Preparation

You’ll need a set of four standard-size ping-pong balls and a permanent marker.

First off, use the marker to draw symbols on the ping-pong balls that denote each base – one symbol per ball: 

  • Single (1)
  • Double (2)
  • Triple (3)
  • Home run (4)

Once they’re marked with their respective symbols, you’ll have four sets ready for gameplay during your fun night.

Table Selection

Choosing the correct type of table for playing the Baseball Drinking Game is essential for having a great time. A large, rectangular, or circular table with enough space on each end to accommodate all your cups and supplies is vital.

Look for a sturdy, stable surface with legs in good condition, and make sure there’s plenty of walking around it when people socialize and play.

Plastic folding tables are a popular choice amongst players; they are lightweight, portable, and also come in different sizes. 

Ensure the table you choose stays firmly on the ground even when strongly bumped during these fun yet intense matches! 

You can also opt for waterproof surfaces so you won’t worry if liquids spill over the side.

Cup Placement

One of the most essential thing in setting up the baseball drinking game is cup placement. Each team must set their cups side by side halfway across the table so that they are split evenly between the two teams and each cup is equidistant from its closest neighbor.

As there may be more than one player on offense or defense, it’s essential to ensure everyone has enough room to throw or defend against potential shots simultaneously.

Additionally, strategic placements can impact how easy or difficult it is for either team to score points: keeping more distance between opposing cups makes it harder for players on offense to land shots into them, though placing too much distance between multiple cups can also create opportunities for an offensive player to swat the ball back-and-forth between them.

Water Filling

Water is a crucial factor when setting up for The Baseball Drinking Game. Water and beer must fill the cups along each side of the table to have an official game.

All four cups must be filled with equal amounts of water, giving both teams an even chance at success or failure. 

If there’s an imbalance between both sides, it may cause one team to win unfairly while simultaneously taking longer than usual as they wait for their turn again.

At the end of each inning, switch out water and clean out any beer spillage from spilled drinks into adjacent glasses! 

Beverage Selection

When selecting a beverage for your game of Baseball Drinking Game, there are several elements to consider. 

First, the type and strength of alcohol are essential; the more potent it is, the quicker people become inebriated.

Beer is one of the most popular choices due to its relatively low ABV (alcohol by volume) level, but hard stuff such as vodka or whiskey can also be used for an extra kick.

Consider also how sweet a drink may be, as this affects flavor preference and the speed at which it’s consumed. 

Some standard mixtures that work well include beer paired with either lime juice or tequila – both lighten up the brew while adding interesting flavor profiles once combined with other ingredients.

Team Role Determination

Playing the Baseball Drinking Game is more enjoyable when each team member has a role to play during the game. These roles can be fluid, as players can switch up depending on the situation, but assigning a permanent role to each team member helps with strategizing and teamwork.

  • The pitcher’s task is to flick the ping-pong ball across the table, looking for it to land in one of your opponent’s cups. 
  • The catcher’s job is typically twofold: keeping track of scores and ensuring no balls land in your cup! 
  • Fielders are responsible for swatting away any ball flying toward their side before it lands in the scoring cups, 
  • Base men synchronize with their offense teammates so they know when to steal bases or hit flip-cup rounds for points.

Assigning roles within teams creates a structure that enhances collaborative goal setting and builds trust, as nobody will feel like another player isn’t doing his fair share.

Defense Positioning

In the Baseball Drinking Game, proper defense positioning can mean the difference between winning and losing. The team on defense must position a player at each cup on the right side of the table and one behind the end of the table.

These players must be aware of where they need to be to prevent pong balls from bouncing off cups or, even worse, going into them.

This helps to ensure that your opponents cannot gain an advantage by throwing specifically angled shots across the table and making sure they don’t make it too easy by simply chucking pong balls into cups without any strategy involved.

Players should be allowed to move out of position when attempting a defensive play; staying in place will allow for better reaction time than quickly moving around after each attempt made by your opponent.

Baseball Drinking Game Rules

The Batter Is Out If

  • Their ping-pong ball does not make it into a cup or, if playing with two players, isn’t caught by the defense.
  • The ball goes out of bounds, meaning it doesn’t have to touch any cups for the batter to be out.
  • They hit more than three balls in one turn and don’t get all four cups filled up before their third shot has been thrown (if playing with more than two players).

Understanding when the batter is out is an essential part of playing the Baseball Drinking Game, as each team’s goal is to score points and fill all four cups on either side of the table. 

Anything that causes them to fail results in an “out” during the gameplay – resulting in no points gained and often leading to costly mistakes during gameplay or potentially even ending a round without getting enough runs scored. 

Keeping track of outs help teams strategize how many hits are needed per player to maximize their scoring chances while minimizing gross errors that would lead to being “out.” 

To score points quickly, teams should understand when they will become “out” and plan accordingly on each turn based on whether additional strikes are necessary to gain a run from a single attack!

After Three Outs, The Teams Switch Offense And Defense

The Baseball Drinking Game is unique because it requires teams to switch between offense and defense after recording three outs. This rule keeps the game fair, ensuring that both teams have a chance to play each role.

Switching sides also help keep players on their toes since they must constantly adapt to different rules and strategies. 

You knowably look for openings in your opponent’s cup placement as an offensive team. In contrast, as a defensive team, you must analyze the strength and accuracy of your opponent’s shots.

You Can Earn A Point By Challenging Your Opponent To Play A Round Of Flip Cup

Integrating Flip Cup into the Baseball Drinking Game is an excellent way to add a new competitive element! 

This variation requires communication and teamwork, so make sure all players understand the rules before beginning.

For each successful challenge to Flip Cup, teams earn one point. Players can try to hit their opponents’ cups with the ping-pong ball and immediately call out “flip cup” as a bonus round when they hit it right in the center.

The two players of each team closest to either end of their table must face off by drinking their beers and flipping over cups on edge simultaneously using only one hand.

The Winner Is The Team With The Most Points

At the end of each round of the Baseball Drinking Game, the team with the most points is declared the winner. 

Points can be earned by successfully throwing a ping-pong ball into one of your opponent’s cups while defending their table, and failing to defend will result in them losing that cup.

Playing a flip-cup against an opponent will also grant a point if won or attempted. 

A successful strategy, quick reflexes, and superior teamwork contribute to whether a team succeeds or fails in gaining points for their side during gameplay.

You Have To Drink If A Ball Lands In Your Cup

Any time a ball lands in one player’s cup, that player must take a sip. That may seem harsh, but it makes sense within the game context: if one team can get fortunate and throw or flick lots of balls into its opponent’s cups, they could win reasonably quickly.

So for your safety, I recommend that each person playing drinks responsibly and paces themselves throughout the game.

Foul Balls

Awareness of the foul ball rule in the Baseball Drinking Game is essential. A foul ball occurs when a ping-pong ball is thrown from one side of the table onto a cup on the opponent’s side.

If a player throws a foul ball, their team must take an extra drink. This means four drinks must be taken if all three tosses are deemed foul balls. 

Additionally, it can be difficult for teams with few players because this would mean more drinking per person.

The consequences can also make it harder for weaker teams to score runs and compete against those with more extensive lineups who statistically may have an easier time avoiding or taking advantage of the extra drink consequence.

Number Of Innings

The number of innings for the Baseball Drinking Game can vary from 6 to 9, with each game length giving players a different experience. The shorter 4-inning game is fast-paced and leads to quicker outcomes, but it also limits the amount of drinking.

A typical 6-inning game has enough time for teams to explore strategies to outpace their opponent.

If you’re looking for an even longer doubleheader style of play, then opt into playing nine innings; however, this requires dedicated drinkers who are up for a marathon session that’ll last late into the night since there will be many rounds not only between players but among additional teammates too.

Removing Steals

Initially, the Baseball Drinking Game included the ability to steal a base. This rule would have players competing in a game of Flip Cup each time they hit and advanced to their desired base.

However, this created excessive extra work and longer game times due to the additional wait between turns (especially if teams weren’t in sync).

The consensus was that removing steals would keep gameplay exciting while allowing teams to challenge each other without sacrificing too much time or effort. 

Without stealing being allowed, it made playing offense simpler and more accessible for those who are just starting with the game.

Additionally, not having to worry about stealers changed how people set up their defenses when on defense creating more scenarios for strategically placing cups and opportunities for putting pressure on your opponent.

Other Fun Drinking Games To Try

The Office Drinking Game

Highlight your favorite show while having a few drinks with friends during game night. To play, assemble your team and choose one player to be the remote controller—they can pick out an episode that everyone’s familiar with while assigning jobs to each team member.

Each time their characters do something funny, drab, or severe—whatever you decide beforehand—have that particular player take a sip from their drink. 

Drunk Mario Kart

The Drunk Mario Kart drinking game is a great way to spice up your next game night. The basic rules are similar to the popular video game: players must complete laps to avoid being eliminated, and each lap presents new challenges.

FAQs on The Baseball Drinking Game

What is a baseball drinking game?

A baseball drinking game is a fun activity where players throw or hit a small ball and drink based on specific rules. It’s played by two or more people and can be customized for different skill levels.

How do you win at a baseball drinking game?

The objective of a baseball drinking game is for one team to outscore the other across multiple innings. The hitters and pitchers compete, and there are additional drinking penalties for specific accomplishments like strikeouts or home runs. The game continues until a team wins.

What are some popular versions of the baseball drinking game?

Some commonly known variations of baseball drinking games include “Russia Ball,” “Reverse Basebrawl,” and “Five Cup.” Each variation has its own rules, scoring systems, and different drink servings allowed based on participants’ preferences.

Are there any safety considerations I should consider while playing?

Ensure legal drinking age, don’t force drinks, set soft limits, don’t drink and drive, take care of intoxicated individuals, have someone responsible nearby for support. Prioritize safety.

Final Take on The Baseball Drinking Game

The Baseball Drinking Game is a great way to add fun and interactive flair to your game night get-togethers. The game brings an element of strategy as you try your luck at chipping the ping-pong ball into one of several cups filled with beer or other alcoholic beverages.

This can be enjoyed among friends 21 and over, preferably with designated drivers, should anyone decide to drink during the game. If safety measures are taken, this can be a great way to liven up any house party or gathering for a truly unforgettable time.

Dan Smullen Beer is my life profile

Hi, I'm Dan, founder of BeerIsMyLife. I've been an avid homebrewer for over ten years, and beer is my true passion. I've traveled all over the world, visiting breweries, tasting beer, as well as making my own batches. I set up this blog to share that experience with you.