Genesee Cream Ale Review: The Rochester Classic Since 1960

3.4/5
American cream ale, 5.2% ABV, 162 calories. Rochester’s regional classic and the style standard for American cream ale since 1960.

Genesee Cream Ale has been brewed in Rochester, New York since 1960, built on a simple pitch: smooth like a lager, crisp like an ale. It briefly became the best-selling ale in the United States, with roughly 1 million barrels a year rolling out of the Rochester brewery at its peak, and it remains a defining example of the American cream ale style.

At a Glance

StyleAmerican Cream Ale
ABV5.2%
Calories162 per 12 fl oz
Carbs15g per 12 fl oz
OriginGenesee Brewing Company, Rochester, New York (introduced 1960)
IngredientsSix-row malt, Apollo hops, top-fermenting yeast, kraeusened for carbonation
Typical priceAround $16 to $20 for a 30-pack in the US, among the cheapest regional beers. Check the button for live pricing
Genesee Cream Ale
Genesee Cream Ale

How it tastes, by the numbers

Genesee Cream Ale pours pale gold with a modest white head. It is brewed with six-row malt and Apollo hops using a top-fermenting ale yeast, then kraeusened (primed with actively fermenting beer) for its natural carbonation, a genuine hybrid technique that gives it lager-like smoothness with ale-style fermentation underneath.

Body
2/5
Bitterness
1/5
Malt sweetness
2/5
Crispness
4/5
Drinkability
4/5
Our tasting scores, 1 (low) to 5 (high).
Genesee Cream Ale close-up
Genesee Cream Ale

The full review

On the palate it delivers a clean, grainy sweetness with almost no hop bitterness, finishing crisp rather than heavy. That crispness is the whole point of the style, it is meant to bridge the gap between a mainstream American lager and something with a bit more character, without asking drinkers to commit to a hoppier or maltier lager or ale.

It has earned two gold medals at the Great American Beer Festival over its six-plus decades on the market, which is a rare achievement for a beer built around approachability rather than intensity.

Genesee Cream Ale remains one of the last widely distributed true American cream ales, a style that mostly disappeared from the mainstream after the 1970s in favor of straight lagers.

“Smooth like a lager, crisp like an ale, the tagline that has held up for over 60 years.”, Genesee Brewing Company

Pros
  • Genuinely smooth, easy-drinking profile
  • Very cheap for a 30-pack
  • Real historical significance for the cream ale style
  • Two Great American Beer Festival gold medals
Cons
  • Not much complexity or hop character
  • Regional distribution outside the Northeast/Midwest is limited
  • Style is unfamiliar to many younger craft drinkers

Who it is for

Anyone who wants an inexpensive, smooth, easy-drinking beer with a bit more history and character than a straight macro lager. If you want to compare it against the current cheap-lager landscape, our best gas station beers guide covers that lineup.

Genesee Cream Ale six-pack
Genesee Cream Ale, six-pack

How to serve Genesee Cream Ale

Serve it cold, straight from the can or bottle, or in a simple pint glass. It needs no special glassware or ceremony, it is built for everyday drinking.

Final score3.4 / 5

FAQs

What is a cream ale?

A cream ale is an American hybrid style, brewed like an ale with top-fermenting yeast but designed to taste smooth and light like a lager, often kraeusened for carbonation.

How old is Genesee Cream Ale?

It was first brewed in 1960 by the Genesee Brewing Company in Rochester, New York, and has been in continuous production ever since.

Is Genesee Cream Ale strong?

At 5.2% ABV it is slightly stronger than most mainstream American lagers, but it drinks lighter than that number suggests.

Dan Smullen Beer is my life profile

Hi, I'm Dan, founder of BeerIsMyLife. I've been an avid homebrewer for over ten years, and beer is my true passion. I've traveled all over the world, visiting breweries, tasting beer, as well as making my own batches. I set up this blog to share that experience with you.