Walk into any liquor store or grocery aisle and there are dozens of beers competing for your attention, before you even consider a local brewery or ordering online. It is no surprise people end up with something they do not enjoy, or keep buying the same safe choice because they know it will not disappoint. Two industry veterans broke down where those mistakes usually happen: Jeremy Kosmicki, brewmaster at Founders Brewing Co. in Grand Rapids, Michigan, and Tom Nielsen, director of brewery operations at Emberside Brewery and a former Sierra Nevada brew specialist.
The first mistake is sticking to one style out of habit rather than curiosity. Kosmicki points to wheat beers, Kolsch, pale ales and session IPAs as accessible entry points beyond lager, while Nielsen recommends a Kolsch, a cask ale, or a darker porter or stout for a change of pace. A closely related mistake is writing off lager entirely as bland. Nielsen notes that mass-market lagers like Bud and Coors used to carry more hop character decades ago, closer to their Czech and German roots, and that craft lagers now cover pale and dark varieties, hoppier Pilsners, and higher-alcohol styles like Bock.
Ignoring good recommendations is another common trap. Kosmicki says he sticks to beers recommended by people he trusts, and staff at a bottle shop or brewery taproom are usually a better source than a random pick off the shelf. Food pairing matters more than people think, too. Nielsen calls porter and fish and chips a classic, spectacular combination, and recommends IPAs with pizza, since the hop bitterness plays well against the sauce’s sweetness.
Season matters as well. Nielsen leans toward higher-ABV, bourbon barrel-aged stouts and porters in cold weather and crisp Pilsners, Helles and Kolsch in summer, while Kosmicki flags fall as the time to grab Oktoberfest beers, both traditional German versions and American takes on the style. Alcohol content is worth checking too, since it hints at body and intensity as much as how buzzed you will get; Kosmicki notes that higher-ABV beers carry a noticeable alcohol warmth similar to wine or a cocktail.
Freshness is where both experts get most emphatic. Most craft beer has a shelf life of three to five months, and buying direct from a brewery tends to get you the freshest product. Storing beer at room temperature is a mistake too, since heat accelerates staling and, in fruited beers, can trigger secondary fermentation that builds pressure inside the can or bottle. Finally, always buying from the grocery store limits your options, since many smaller breweries only sell through their own taproom or specialty bottle shops rather than supermarket shelves.
Related Reading on Beer Is My Life
- How to Read a Beer Label
- All-Grain vs Extract Brewing: Which One You Should Actually Start With
- Best Beer Advent Calendars 2026: Boxed Picks and How to Build Your Own
- Beer Trivia: Facts Most Drinkers Do Not Know
- Lager Brands: From Budweiser to Craft, the Real Global Lineup
- What Is a Hazy IPA? The New England IPA Style Explained
- Best Oatmeal Stouts to Try
- DOT Brew Side Step IPA Review: The Aldi Rye IPA With Two World Beer Awards
