Cold IPA vs. IPA: What Is Actually Different

I was skeptical about cold IPA the first time I tried one, expecting something closer to a lager with hops bolted on, but it genuinely reads as its own thing. Cold IPA is a real, coherent style with a known inventor and a known first release date, October 2018, brewed by Kevin Davey at Wayfinder Beer in Portland, Oregon, as “Relapse IPA” (a tribute to the 30th anniversary of heavy-metal label Relapse Records). It’s easy to confuse with an India Pale Lager, but the two are built differently, and Davey himself pushes back on the mix-up whenever it comes up.

Where Cold IPA Came From

Davey, Wayfinder’s brewmaster, has said he wanted a lager brewer’s answer to the Brut IPA trend: something lighter and more refreshing than a typical hazy or West Coast IPA, brewed using techniques closer to a clean American lager. The name was deliberately a little tongue-in-cheek. As Davey put it: “we brought up the obvious complaint that all IPAs are cold and it doesn’t make sense… Asahi Super Dry is actually super-wet. There is no milk in cream ale.” Wayfinder’s Original Cold IPA (about 7% ABV, 70+ IBUs, roughly 30% rice in the grist) went on to become one of Craft Beer & Brewing’s Best 20 Beers in 2020, and the style spread from there: brewers as far afield as Spain, Poland and Japan began emailing Davey asking how to brew it.

Cans of Wayfinder Cold IPA, the beer that originated the style
Wayfinder’s Original Cold IPA, first brewed in October 2018 by Kevin Davey, originated the style.

Cold IPA vs. Regular IPA vs. IPL

A standard West Coast IPA is ale-fermented with a caramel-leaning malt bill and warm fermentation temperatures that produce some ester character. Cold IPA strips that back: it’s fermented with lager yeast (or a fast-fermenting, low-ester ale yeast) at relatively warm, ale-like temperatures, using an adjunct-heavy grist (20-40% rice or corn, mashed with American two-row pilsner malt, with no caramel malt at all). The result ferments out drier, 82-88% apparent attenuation, giving a clean, snappy, brisk finish that Davey describes as “wester than West Coast.”

India Pale Lager (IPL) is a different animal, and one Davey specifically built cold IPA to avoid. As brewmaster Shaun O’Sullivan of 21st Amendment describes it, IPLs are “essentially repurposed IPA recipes with their complex malt structure but brewed with a lager yeast,” and the caramel malt stays in, only the yeast strain changes, which often clashes with modern IPA hop character. Cold IPA rebuilds the whole grain bill around the adjunct-lager tradition instead of just swapping yeast into an unchanged IPA recipe.

A glass of West Coast IPA with fresh hop cones
A standard West Coast IPA keeps some caramel malt and ale-fermentation esters that cold IPA strips away entirely.
TraitWest Coast IPACold IPAIPL
Malt billPale malt + some caramelPilsner malt + 20-40% rice/corn, no caramelStandard IPA malt bill, unchanged
YeastAmerican ale yeast, warmLager (or fast/clean ale) yeast, warmLager yeast, cold
AttenuationModerateVery high (82-88%)Moderate
FinishSome malt sweetnessDry, crisp, cleanCan clash: lager esters vs. modern hops

How Cold IPA Is Actually Built

Per Davey’s own published guidance, a proper cold IPA grist runs 20-40% rice or corn, mashed with all-American two-row pilsner malt, with no caramel malt allowed. Fermentation uses a quick, clean, low-ester and low-sulfur lager yeast (Fermentis SafLager W-34/70 is a commonly cited choice) at warmer-than-typical lager temperatures, similar to how a Kolsch, altbier or California common is fermented. Dry hopping happens warm, during spunding or krausening, to achieve biotransformation while limiting oxygen pickup, and the finished beer is filtered crystal clear with lively carbonation, deliberately positioned as “the antithesis of NEIPA,” per Wayfinder’s own description of the style.

Cold IPAs You Can Actually Buy

The style caught on fast beyond Wayfinder. Firestone Walker relaunched its West Coast IPA Hopnosis under the “Cold IPA” name in January 2023, with brewmaster Matt Brynildson explaining the switch: “when you use a lager yeast to ferment an IPA, you get a cleaner and less ester-driven aroma profile. The colder fermentation also creates a lighter backbone that helps accentuate the bright, tropical hops we’re using.” Firestone Walker later scaled the same base up into Double Hopnosis, an 8.3% ABV Imperial Cold IPA. Two easier-to-find cold IPAs worth trying if you want to taste the difference for yourself:

A six-pack of Rogue Ales Knuckle Buster Cold IPA
Rogue’s Knuckle Buster, a 6.1% ABV, 60 IBU cold IPA brewed with Superior Pils malt and flaked rice.

Rogue’s take, a collaboration with Austin motorcycle shop Revival Cycles, leans on Hallertauer Blanc, Belma, Nelson Sauvin, Motueka, Comet and Cascade hops over a light body, described by the brewery as “a cross between a pilsner and an IPA.” Widmer Brothers’ Cold Waters runs a stronger 6.7% ABV and sticks closer to the classic West Coast hop profile, which makes a decent side-by-side with a straight West Coast IPA if you want to feel the difference in body rather than just read about it.

A six-pack of Widmer Brothers Cold Waters Cold IPA
Widmer Brothers’ Cold Waters runs 6.7% ABV, closer to a standard West Coast IPA’s strength.

Serving Cold IPA the Right Way

Because the whole point of the style is a crisp, clean finish, serving temperature matters more here than with a hazy or West Coast IPA. Aim for 38-42degF, closer to how you’d serve a pilsner than a typical ale, in a tall, narrow pilsner glass rather than a wide tulip or snifter. Warming it up the way you might with a West Coast IPA to “open up” the hops works against the style: cold IPA is built to be crisp and a little aggressive on carbonation, and it loses that edge fast once it warms past around 45degF.

FAQs

Is cold IPA the same as India Pale Lager (IPL)?
No. IPL usually takes an unchanged IPA recipe and swaps in lager yeast, which can clash with modern hop character. Cold IPA rebuilds the grain bill around an adjunct-lager base (rice or corn, no caramel malt) specifically to avoid that clash.

Who invented cold IPA?
Kevin Davey, brewmaster at Wayfinder Beer in Portland, Oregon, who first brewed it in October 2018 as “Relapse IPA.”

Does cold IPA taste like a hazy IPA?
No, the opposite. Cold IPA is filtered crystal clear, dry and crisp, explicitly built as a contrast to the cloudy, juicy, low-bitterness profile of a New England-style IPA.

References:
  • Wayfinder Beer, brewer Kevin Davey’s own account of Original Cold IPA
  • Firestone Walker, brewmaster Matt Brynildson on the Hopnosis renaming
Dan Smullen Beer is my life profile

Hi, I'm Dan, founder of BeerIsMyLife. I've been an avid homebrewer for over ten years, and beer is my true passion. I've traveled all over the world, visiting breweries, tasting beer, as well as making my own batches. I set up this blog to share that experience with you.