Every fall, pumpkin beer shows up on tap lists from Maine to California, but the country is not nearly as united on it as the shelf space suggests. I pulled regional search-interest data for “pumpkin beer” across all 50 states plus DC, and the result is less a gentle gradient than a border. On one side, New Hampshire, Rhode Island and Massachusetts are obsessed. On the other, four states barely register a pulse at all.

New Hampshire Earns the Crown
New Hampshire searches for pumpkin beer harder than any other state in the country, scoring a perfect 100 on a 0-100 relative scale. Rhode Island (87) and Massachusetts (78) are right behind it, and Maine and Connecticut both crack the top seven. Put plainly: New England doesn’t just like pumpkin beer, it has built a regional identity around it.
There’s a real reason for that, and it has a name: Pumpkinhead Ale. Shipyard Brewing debuted it as a one-off at Federal Jack’s brewpub in Kennebunk, Maine, back in 1997. It caught on so fast that it now accounts for roughly 40 percent of Shipyard’s annual production despite only being on shelves for about three months a year. Somewhere along the way, Massachusetts bartenders started rimming the glass with cinnamon and sugar, a regional ritual that caught on nationally. A beer that began as a single seasonal batch in a small coastal town is now the reason an entire region out-searches the rest of America for the category.
The Great Pumpkin Beer Divide
Scroll down the list and the picture flips entirely. Texas and Alabama sit at 10. Oklahoma is at 8, Louisiana at 7. Alaska registers a single point. North Dakota, South Dakota, Hawaii and Mississippi all come back at zero, meaning there isn’t enough consistent search volume for the phrase in those states to register on the scale at all.

This isn’t just a story about a shorter autumn. Delivery data from DoorDash on fall flavor preference backs up the same regional split: apple is the dominant fall flavor across 18 states in the South and Mid-Atlantic, while several New England states lead the country on cinnamon and spice-forward orders. The South has its own seasonal flavor loyalties, and pumpkin simply is not one of them. Pair that with a craft beer scene that is denser per capita in the Northeast and a seasonal release calendar that New England breweries lean on harder than anywhere else, and the gap in the data starts to make a lot more sense.
Full Top 15
- New Hampshire, 100
- Rhode Island, 87
- Massachusetts, 78
- Pennsylvania, 57
- Washington, 51
- Maine, 51
- Connecticut, 48
- Delaware, 44
- Wyoming, 42
- New York, 42
- Ohio, 39
- Colorado, 39
- Montana, 39
- Vermont, 33
- New Jersey, 33
Four of the top seven are in New England, and the only state outside the Northeast or Mountain West to crack the top 10 is Washington, home to its own dense seasonal craft beer culture in Seattle and Portland’s backyard.
How I Pulled This
I used Google’s regional search-interest data for the exact phrase “pumpkin beer” across the United States, covering the most recent 12-month window through mid-October 2026. Each state gets a score from 0 to 100 relative to the single highest-scoring state, so this measures how search-hungry a state’s population is for the term relative to its own overall search volume, not which state has the most beer drinkers or the biggest population.
If your state made the top of the list and you want a pick worth the hype, I ran the numbers on what’s actually worth drinking this season in my Best Fall Beers guide, and the Best Beers for a Halloween Party list has eight more spooky-season options if you’re planning around the holiday itself. And if your state landed near the bottom, my running state-by-state list of America’s Best-Kept Secret Beers is a better bet than fighting the pumpkin ale shelf for something nobody around you is searching for anyway.
